The fourth night is over, and Shmoop is still mopey and mopey. He's not sure what to do with himself now that he's done with the girl, but he promises to keep her company for as long as he can. He also tells her about the secret conversation he had with the other guy, and she asks him how he knew about it, and he says that it was not just him, but all of them. She wants to know how he could have known about the meeting with the guy, so he tells her that he saw the guy in the street, but that he couldn't make out the man's face because he was wearing glasses and a mask. She asks him why he didn't tell her about it. He says that if she had seen him, she'd know that he was the man she saw, and that she should tell the whole story to everyone.