Now that everything is ready, it's time for the pigeon to deliver the letter to Oliver. Oliver is all, "Don't worry, I've already killed the letter" . He tells Oliver that he'll never see his brother again. Oliver says he's not going to hurt anyone's innocent life again, and he promises to protect Oliver by his side. Oliver thanks the duke and says they've spread the rumor about the pigeons. Oliver wants to know who told the duke to spread these rumors, and the duke says he doesn't know. Oliver asks who told him to do it. The duke says it was him. Oliver begs the duke not to kill him.